Newspaper Claim About Ted Cruz’s Desire To ‘Restrict’ Preferred Pronouns Goes Viral

A headline that appeared in the San Antonio Express-News on Thursday alleged that Sen. Ted Cruz (R–Texas) had put forth a bill that would “restrict the use of preferred names, pronouns,” pointing out that the senator himself uses a preferred nickname, not his legal name. The publication tweeted a link to the story echoing the same assertion, and it quickly gathered over 6 million views on X, formerly Twitter, by Friday afternoon.

“We already knew that Republicans were synonymous with hypocrisy, but this is so typical of them. How is it no one ever calls them out on it?” read one reply.

“I don’t see how this is remotely constitutional,” another commenter added.

However, the bill introduced by Cruz doesn’t restrict individuals’ ability to honor preferred names or pronouns for transgender people. Instead, it would forbid the government from enforcing any rule compelling its employees to use preferred pronouns or names. Instead of mandating speech, the bill prevents the government from attempting to force speech from their employees.

While the article headline was eventually updated to accurately reflect the bill’s content, the original viral post remains online at the time of publication.

The “Safeguarding Honest Speech Act,” introduced by Cruz and Rep. Andy Ogles (R–Tenn.) in November, states that “No Federal funds may be used for the purpose of implementing, administering, or enforcing any rule…requiring an employee or contractor of any Federal agency or Department to use—(1) another person’s preferred pronouns if they are incompatible with such person’s sex; or (2) a name other than a person’s legal name when referring to such person.”

And the bill would likely reinforce existing First Amendment protections.

“Public employees retain First Amendment rights to speak as private citizens, so insofar a pronoun use touches on a contentious social issue, the subject cannot fully avoid addressing a matter of public concern,” reads a write-up from the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), a First Amendment nonprofit. “Government employers may not penalize employees for their speech as private citizens on matters of public concern without proving an interest in workplace efficiency…that outweighs the employee’s expressive rights.”

Nevertheless, FIRE notes that some forms of refusing to use preferred names or pronouns, also known as “misgendering,” could come under scrutiny. “Under workplace anti-discrimination law, knowingly and repeatedly using a colleague’s non-preferred pronouns could be part of a pattern of conduct severe or pervasive enough to create a hostile work environment.” But even with this exception, “the government would not be justified in compelling employees to use certain pronouns.”

While choosing not to use a transgender person’s preferred name or pronouns may be considered impolite or mean-spirited, outside of limited exceptions, doing so is a form of First Amendment–protected speech.

It’s also more than possible to criticize Cruz’s stance on transgender rights without making misleading claims about legislation he introduces. 

More Reading

Post navigation

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *