In August 2019, Elijah McClain, a 23-year-old masseur, was stopped by police officers while walking home from a convenience store in Aurora, Colorado, where he had purchased three cans of iced tea. McClain, who had not broken any laws, did not understand why he was being detained and his objections led to an increase in force, ultimately resulting in an injection of ketamine that left him unconscious and, ultimately, fatal. His case garnered national attention following George Floyd’s death, drawing notable similarities in the treatment of both men by police officers. The aftermath has brought a mix of verdicts that reflect a series of mistakes that led to a fatal outcome.
Recently, a jury found Peter Cichuniec and Jeremy Cooper guilty of criminally negligent homicide for administering an overdose of ketamine to McClain, with Cichuniec also convicted of second-degree assault. Both individuals face potential prison time. These verdicts followed previous convictions and acquittals of other involved officers in separate trials.
After McClain’s death, local prosecutors initially chose not to press charges, prompting criticism and a new investigation by Colorado Governor Jared Polis. This second investigation led to multiple charges against the officers and paramedics involved. The subsequent trials and varying verdicts have brought to light previous inadequacies in the investigation process.
When McClain was approached by Officer Woodyard, the encounter quickly escalated despite no clear evidence of criminal activity. The subsequent actions of the officers led to an unjustified arrest, culminating in a tragic outcome.
The decision to escalate the encounter and subsequent actions by the officers did not align with legal requirements, ultimately leading to a violation of McClain’s rights and a fatal result.
As the encounter progressed, the officers made decisions that elevated the situation without adequate justification, ultimately resulting in tragedy.
a test the police had already failed to meet. While the police were attempting, without any legal justification, to compel McClain onto the grassy area, Roedema informed Rosenblatt, “He seized your gun, dude.” According to Woodyard, that warning “changed the situation.” Upon hearing Roedema’s caution, Woodyard chose to “take [McClain] down to the ground as hard as I could.” When tackling McClain, Woodyard twice tried to apply a “carotid control hold,” intending to induce unconsciousness by applying pressure on both sides of the neck to cut off blood flow to the brain. The second, more successful attempt occurred when McClain was pinned on the ground.
After regaining consciousness, he vomited repeatedly. He was handcuffed and still wore his ski mask, and an autopsy revealed that he had breathed in some of the vomit. That, combined with the downward pressure the officers were applying, explains his difficulty in breathing.
At his trial, Woodyard stated that he used the carotid control in self-defense. “I intend to take my power back,” McClain had said. Woodyard mentioned that remark and Roedema’s warning about Rosenblatt’s gun made him fear for his life. However, the prosecutors pointed out that Rosenblatt later said he had not felt anyone touch his gun, and body camera footage showed no such movement by McClain.
McClain was five feet, seven inches tall and weighed about 140 pounds. Nevertheless, the officers claimed he displayed “crazy,” “incredible,” “superhuman” strength, which they attributed to “excited delerium” caused by “whatever he’s on.” Toxicological tests revealed that marijuana was the only psychoactive substance that McClain had consumed. In any case, “excited delerium” is a scientifically dubious concept that is not acknowledged by the American Medical Association, the American Psychiatric Association, or the World Health Organization. This term mainly serves to justify what would otherwise seem like excessive force.
Forensic pathologist Roger A. Mitchell Jr., who testified during Roedema and Rosenblatt’s trial, made it clear that he does not view “excited delerium” as a valid diagnosis. But even if it were, he said, McClain’s behavior did not match the usual description of the condition. “He’s communicating with law enforcement,” Mitchell said. “He’s clear on what’s going on with him. He’s pleading his case.” Mitchell also noted that McClain’s exclamations showed he was responding to the pain caused by the officers. “If we believe this notion of excited delirium,” he said, “one of the things with excited delirium is that you’re impervious to pain.”
Cichuniec and Cooper, who arrived 11 minutes after Woodyard first approached McClain, nevertheless concurred with the officers’ diagnosis. The indictment stated that they reached that conclusion “after receiving some information from officers and observing Mr. McClain for about one minute.” Neither paramedic “ascertained Mr. McClain’s vital signs,” the indictment notes. “Nor did either of them talk to or physically touch Mr. McClain before diagnosing him with excited delirium.”
They decided that the appropriate treatment was an injection of ketamine. No one at the scene questioned that decision. “Yep, sounds good,” Rosenblatt said when Cooper announced that he planned to inject McClain with ketamine. “Perfect, dude, perfect,” Roedema agreed.
Adding to the series of mistakes, Cooper administered 500 milligrams of ketamine. The correct dose for a 143-pound man would have been 325 milligrams, so McClain was given about 50 percent more than he should have received. Cooper never asked McClain his weight, instead estimating it to be about 200 pounds. Even if that estimate had been correct, the dosage still would have been about 50 milligrams too high.
During the paramedics’ trial, Colorado Public Radio reported, “Cooper and Cichuniec said they didn’t hear a police supervisor on the scene, Sgt. Dale Leonard, tell them a few details about what happened, including that McClain had received two carotid holds, which cut blood flow off to his brain, and that he had been vomiting repeatedly ever since.” That information was relevant because ketamine can suppress respiration, which is especially problematic for someone whose breathing is already compromised.
Prosecutors argued that the paramedics failed to properly monitor McClain. “After McClain was given a large dose of ketamine by paramedics,” Colorado Public Radio noted, “body worn camera footage shows that they didn’t immediately tend to him, check his airway or otherwise look at his vital signs.” Pulmonologist David Beuther testified that closer attention could have saved McClain’s life. If a patient is “a little too sleepy” and “starting to slip into deep sedation,” he said, you can reposition his head or use “a little plastic tube” to aid breathing.
By the time McClain was lifted onto a gurney, he was unconscious and snoring, which can indicate an overdose. In the ambulance, paramedics found that McClain had no pulse and was not breathing. They revived him with CPR and epinephrine, but he never regained consciousness.
The original autopsy report listed both the cause and manner of death as unknown. Stephen Cina, the pathologist who wrote the report, later revised it in light of information discovered by Weiser’s investigation. The amended report describes the cause of death as “complications of ketamine administration following forcible restraint” but still lists the manner of death as “undetermined.” Mitchell testified that he agreed with Cina about the cause of death but thought it was clear that the manner was homicide.
That characterization, which does not necessarily imply criminal liability, seems hard to deny, since it is clear that McClain would not have died if the police and paramedics had left him alone. The question of how to allocate the legal responsibility for his death is more complicated, given all the things that went wrong that night. The police argued that the paramedics were mainly to blame. “Elijah McClain would not have died but for the ketamine,” one of Roedema’s lawyers told the jury. Cooper and Cichuniec argued that the police were mainly to blame, since they controlled the scene, provided the information on which the paramedics relied, and caused the vomiting that may have contributed to McClain’s death.
Why was Rosenblatt acquitted? He had less experience than the other officers, and his lawyer, Harvey Steinberg,Said that Rosenblatt was simply obeying commands. In contrast, Roedema, as the senior officer on site, treated McClain more aggressively than Rosenblatt.
The charges state that Roedema employed a “bar hammer lock,” a “physical defensive tactic where a person’s arm is held back behind their back to control them.” Roedema “claimed that he ‘cranked pretty hard’ on Mr. McClain’s shoulder and heard it pop three times.” Steinberg Suggested that Rosenblatt was less forceful and therefore less responsible: “Rosenblatt didn’t jerk his arm. It was Roedema. Rosenblatt didn’t have his knee in his back. It was Roedema.” It was also Roedema who asserted, likely inaccurately, that McClain was attempting to grab Rosenblatt’s firearm, which everyone agreed significantly escalated the violence.
Woodyard’s acquittal is more challenging to comprehend. He initiated the use of force, setting the tone for the entire encounter. Not only did he use a carotid hold, but he did so twice, contrary to department policy. However, Woodyard faced a different jury than Roedema, and this jury may have been more inclined to believe the claim that the officers were acting in self-defense.
Woodyard, a police officer for about two years at the time, “tearfully told jurors he was weeping to his supervisor on the scene because he was fearful that he was going to die and needed to step away,” Colorado Public Radio Reported. The officer’s lawyer, Andrew Ho, portrayed him as a bystander. “Nathan Woodyard entrusted Elijah McClain to the care and custody of his fellow officers and entrusted Elijah McClain to medically trained professionals,” Ho said. “Nathan Woodyard did not kill Elijah. He’s not responsible for what other people did or did not do.”
Was anyone accountable? “Simply because there’s a tragedy doesn’t mean there’s criminality,” one of Roedema’s attorneys Said during closing arguments. But prosecutor Duane Lyons stressed that the officers had not followed their training. “They were instructed what to do,” he said. “It didn’t have to be this way…They were given instructions, they had opportunities, and they failed to choose to de-escalate violence when they needed to.” He also blamed them for neglecting to check McClain’s breathing. “This is not just a tragedy,” he said. “This is a crime.”

Leave a Comment