In 2017, the tragic Las Vegas shooting that claimed 61 lives and injured approximately 500 people, led to a nationwide outcry. This incident prompted then-President Donald Trump to advocate for the prohibition of certain firearm accessories. The accessory in question was a bump stock, a device that enables a legal semi-automatic weapon to discharge hundreds of bullets within minutes.
Trump’s Bureau of Alcohol, Firearms and Tobacco (ATF) issued an interpretive rule stating that bump stocks, previously considered outside the scope of a decades-old machine gun ban, were indeed in violation of the National Firearms Act of 1934.
On Wednesday, the Supreme Court heard arguments from Jonathan Mitchell, an attorney representing Michael Cargill, owner of Central Texas Gun Works. Cargill was opposed to surrendering his bump stocks and challenged the new rule on several grounds. Mitchell is well-known for his involvement in high-profile cultural cases such as crafting the “bounty hunter” abortion law in Texas.
The ‘Same Thing’
The liberal justices focused their discussion on whether the operation of a bump stock – which involves moving part of the gun back and forth quickly after initially pulling the trigger – qualifies under the law as shooting “automatically” “by a single function of the trigger”.
“I view myself as a good textualist,” Justice Elena Kagan stated. “But textualism is not inconsistent with common sense.”
Kagan argued that both traditional machine guns and firearms equipped with bump stocks fire multiple shots with one human action and should therefore be treated similarly under law.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson echoed Kagan’s sentiments during her questioning. She pointed out that Congress intended to ban weapons capable of discharging hundreds of bullets within seconds, regardless if they operate exactly like an M16.
Surprisingly, Justice Clarence Thomas, a stalwart conservative voice on the Court, joined this line of argument. Thomas authored the majority opinion in a 2022 ruling that overturned a century-old New York gun control law and paved the way for challenging many more such laws.
Think Of The Bump Stockers
The conservative justices, including Justices Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Samuel Alito, expressed concerns about the potential confusion among bump stock owners due to the changed rule. They questioned whether these individuals would be aware that their equipment was no longer legal and could potentially violate ATF regulations.
Gorsuch sarcastically commented on the likelihood of gun owners reading the federal register for fun in their spare time. He also challenged Fletcher’s interpretation of the word “function” in the statute.
Alito expressed concern about potential legal confusion among people residing within the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals’ jurisdiction. Despite Fletcher’s reassurances that the government does not intend to prosecute individuals who owned bump stocks prior to the rule change, Alito remained skeptical.
Gorsuch also criticized ATF’s process of changing rules. He pointed out that for many years, multiple administrations had held that bump stocks were not machine guns. Then suddenly an interpretive rule was adopted stating otherwise, potentially turning hundreds of thousands of people into federal felons overnight.
Fletcher responded by stating there are procedures in place to ensure those who owned bump stocks while they were legal aren’t unfairly prosecuted. He argued this is not a reason to restrict ATF or prevent it from adopting what it believes is the best interpretation of Congress’ words.

Leave a Comment