You have likely already seen or heard about the public inquiry involving prestigious university leaders (Harvard, Penn, MIT) dispassionately discussing the need for context and citing technical requirements when asked if it would breach the university’s code of behavior to advocate for the extermination of Jews. The viral clip is truly startling.
While watching it, I found myself not questioning why these administrators are such awful anti-Semites but rather, how did all three end up in this situation providing these responses?
Firstly, the clip was shared by Rep. Elise Stefanik, a consistently unpleasant and dishonest person who represents a district in Upstate New York. Stefanik is very much the kind of person you’ll see dramatically demanding direct answers to tricky questions at a congressional hearing. Even so, in this case, she seemed to obtain them.
Upon watching the responses from the three university presidents, each one was somewhat awkwardly aiming for the same conclusion: determining if a call for “the genocide of Jews” would breach university policy would depend on the context and specifically whether the speech had turned into “conduct” and if it targeted specific individuals. These are valid criteria for policies on harassment and bullying. But advocating for the extermination of any distinct group would likely be a threat to every member of that group, intentionally.
How did this happen? How did these three end up with the same extremely poor set of responses as Penn President Liz Magill acknowledged in a subsequent apology video released a day later? A New York Times columnist Michele Goldberg reviewed the whole hearing and found a related context. Goldberg mentioned that watching the full hearing before the now infamous exchange made the responses more understandable. During questioning before the exchange, Rep. Stefanik laid a trap.
So later in the hearing, when Stefanik again started questioning Gay, Kornbluth and Magill about whether it was permissible for students to call for the genocide of the Jews, she was referring, it seemed clear, to common pro-Palestinian rhetoric and trying to get the university presidents to commit to disciplining those who use it.
This doesn’t close the book on the broader question of double standards in a university context. The flubbed responses are linked to a framework of social justice politics that doesn’t exclude Jews but simply doesn’t have an obvious place for them. But it does provide some helpful background in explaining how this communication debacle occurred.
There is a complex double standard at play. Jews and their allies have made Anti-Semitism, when identified as such, entirely forbidden and have a strong network of groups aimed at identifying and rejecting it. At the same time, demonizing rhetoric about Jews is evaluated based on whether and what Jews might have done to deserve it. Both aspects manage to be somewhat true at the same time.
In recent years, many academic institutions have adopted ways of handling speech questions that prioritize the subjective experience of individuals and specific groups. However, that framework is inherently problematic and difficult to apply objectively. There is evidence that it’s not consistently applied with respect to Jews on college campuses. A better approach would be to reconsider the standard itself.

Leave a Comment