Some activists argue that the criminal justice system is prejudiced because of the higher rate of incarceration for Black individuals compared to White individuals. However, this overlooks the fact that the rate of criminal activity is higher among Black individuals than White individuals. When considering the higher rate of criminal activity among Black individuals, it becomes evident that the criminal justice system treats Black and White individuals similarly in the majority of cases.
“Overall, the criminal justice system appears to be extremely impartial” and fair in how it treats people of different races, according to a newly released meta-analysis. The study found that race does not reliably predict most criminal sentencing outcomes. “Overall results suggested that neither class nor race biases for criminal adjudications for either violent or property crimes could be reliably detected,” reports the research, “Race, class, and criminal adjudication: Is the US criminal justice system as biased as is often assumed? A meta-analytic review.” It is published in Aggression and Violent Behavior, a peer-reviewed scientific journal published by the leading academic publisher Elsevier.
This discovery that the criminal justice system is racially just aligns with a recent government study as well.
A 2021 study by the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics found that while Black individuals are arrested for serious nonfatal violent crimes at a much higher rate than White individuals, this primarily reflects underlying crime rates, not racism: “white and Black people were arrested proportionate to their involvement in serious nonfatal violent crime overall and proportionate to their involvement in serious nonfatal violent crime reported to police.” (See Allen J. Beck, Race and Ethnicity of Violent Crime Offenders and Arrestees, 2018). The fact that the percentage of Black people arrested is similar to the percentage of Black perpetrators of “crime reported to police” is significant because the individuals reporting violent crimes to police – primarily the victims – are disproportionately Black individuals themselves. Since victims are overwhelmingly the same race as their attacker, there is no reason to believe that they are reporting those crimes due to racism. Most crimes against Black individuals are committed by other Black individuals, according to the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics. According to FBI data, 89 percent of Black individuals who were murdered in 2018 were killed by Black offenders.
Other studies have also found that the criminal justice system is racially impartial in significant ways. The RAND Corporation’s statistical expert Dr. Stephen P. Klein, a progressive researcher, thoroughly examined California’s state criminal justice system and, while accounting for relevant factors, determined that criminal sentencing in California was impartial and non-discriminatory overall, and that similarly-situated Black and White individuals in California received very similar sentences. (See Stephen P. Klein, et al., “Race and Imprisonment Decisions in California,” 247 Science 812 (1990)).
Likewise, a 1991 RAND Corporation study of adult robbery and burglary defendants in 14 large U.S. cities found that a defendant’s race or ethnic group had almost no bearing on conviction rates, severity of sentencing, or other key measures. In 1994, federal government statistician Patrick A. Langan analyzed data on 42,500 defendants in the nation’s 75 largest counties and discovered “no evidence that, in the places where Black individuals in the United States have most of their encounters with the justice system, that system treats them more harshly than White individuals.” As he pointed out, “No Racism in the Justice System,” “Many studies have been conducted that show no bias in the arrest, prosecution, adjudication, and sentencing of Black individuals,” while “other studies show possible evidence of bias.”
So why are Black individuals overrepresented in America’s prisons? The higher rate of criminal activity among Black individuals. Rates of committing homicide “for Black individuals were more than 7 times higher than the rates for White individuals” between 1976 and 2005, according to the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics in its publication, Homicide Trends in the United States. In 2019, 6,425 Black individuals committed homicide, compared to only 4,728 White individuals, according to the FBI’s Uniform Crime Report.
Racial disparities in incarceration rates are not a result of “White supremacy.” If they were, the Asian incarceration rate would be higher than the White incarceration rate. However, the opposite is true: Asians, who are not White, have the lowest incarceration rate by far, of any race. Asians represent 15% of California’s population, but only 2% of its jail population — a significant racial difference. Nationally, fewer uniforms
Less than 2% of the jail population is made up of Asian or Pacific Islander individuals, even though they represent over 6% of the U.S. population.
Some progressives argue that pointing out the higher black crime rate compared to the white crime rate is racist or that if the black crime rate is indeed higher, it’s society’s fault. In response to this analysis, a prominent progressive on X (formerly known as Twitter) mentioned that since “minority populations are over-represented in prisons,” one must believe either that minorities “are essentially more violent,” or that the legal system is to blame because it “is built to justify condemning different cultures” or to deny minorities “a good defense.” Not believing the latter is labeled as “bigotry,” according to him.
However, there are other possibilities. The black crime rate could be higher due to cultural reasons, not solely because they are “essentially more violent.” After all, blacks in America lived for generations in criminogenic cultural environments, and blacks today mostly grow up in single-parent households, which disproportionately produce criminals.
According to the City Journal, “Over 70 percent of black children are born out of wedlock, far higher than in any other racial group. The social science correlating fatherlessness with criminal behavior is overwhelming.” The rate of single-parent families among black Americans has remained at around 65% for the past decade, much higher than non-Hispanic whites with a rate of 24% and Asian-Americans with the lowest rate at 15%.
Most blacks once lived in the Deep South, which historically had a higher crime rate than most of the U.S. due to cultural reasons. Even before blacks were influenced by that culture, they already carried with them the habits of African cultures where killing was routine and human life was regarded as cheap.”
Long before Europeans arrived, Igbos enslaved other Igbos as punishment for crimes, for the payment of debts, and as prisoners of war … they were also sometimes sacrificed in religious ceremonies or buried alive with their masters to serve them in the next life. When the transatlantic trade began, in the fifteenth century, the demand for slaves spiked. Igbo traders began kidnapping people from distant villages.
African cultures had underdeveloped legal systems and traditions of using violence to resolve disputes. Black slaves were imported into the most violent part of America, the Deep South, which likely had negative effects on law and order in the black community.
Black economist Thomas Sowell theorized that Southern blacks adopted the violent honor culture of Southern whites and carried it into the North during the Great Migration. He noted that the Southern black crime rate was five times higher than that among Northern-born blacks.
Furthermore, ignoring black-on-black crime has historically fueled crime in the black community. Since most violent crimes by blacks are against other blacks, turning a blind eye to such crimes results in a higher black crime rate than the white crime rate.
The racial differences in arrest rates today do not necessarily prove racism by the police making the arrests. The Supreme Court emphasized that there is no legal “presumption that people of all races commit all types of crimes” at the same rate. Therefore, racial disparities in arrest or incarceration rates don’t violate the Constitution’s ban on racial discrimination.

Leave a Comment