Charter Schools Outperform Public Schools with Less Funding!

Charter schools offer students greater educational progress for each dollar spent compared to traditional public schools (TPS). That’s the conclusion of a recent study by researchers from the University of Arkansas who examined public and charter schools in nine American cities. Despite obtaining significantly less funding per student than TPS, students in charter schools perform better and are projected to earn more for every dollar invested in their education.

“Charter schools efficiently utilize their funding, achieving superior short- and long-term results per dollar invested, in comparison to” traditional public schools (TPS), the study notes. “Compared to similar TPS students, charter school students, on average, show slightly better performance on standardized tests, have higher high school graduation rates, exhibit higher college enrollment rates, and display more positive behavioral outcomes.”

In the nine cities examined by the researchers, public schools received an average of $29,168 per student in FY 2020. Charter schools received about 70 percent of that amount, at only $20,230 per student. Nevertheless, despite this disparity, students in charter schools achieved several points higher on a national standardized test.

Although the actual performance gap between the average public school student and charter school student was relatively small—ranging from 0.05 to 0.07 of a standard deviation depending on the year examined—the researchers argued that, given the substantial funding gap, this small difference holds significance.

The researchers estimated that across the nine cities, for every $1 spent per student, public school students can anticipate $3.94 in lifetime earnings. However, for charter schools, that figure rises to $6.25, indicating that the return on investment for students attending charter schools is 58 percent higher on average than for those attending traditional public schools. In two of the cities analyzed, charter schools delivered a 100 percent higher return on investment than TPS.

“Charter schools generally demonstrate greater efficiency in both measures of cost-effectiveness and return on investment, utilizing fewer funds to achieve superior results,” the researcher wrote. “Part of the mechanism that enables charter schools to achieve better results with less funding could be associated with the fact that charter schools are exempt from certain restrictions imposed on public schools, allowing them to tailor their spending to be more efficient and deliver better outcomes for students.”

These findings are hardly surprising. While it has long been a common belief in progressive politics that increased funding is the crucial factor in enhancing school performance, per-pupil spending actually has a weak correlation with academic outcomes.

A 2012 study by researchers from Harvard and Stanford found that an additional $1,000 in per-pupil expenditure was “linked with a yearly gain in achievement of one-tenth of 1 percent of a standard deviation,” and noted that such a small amount “lacks statistical or substantive significance.”

While individual charter school performances differ, reports like this demonstrate that charters are a solid academic choice—one that seems to deliver similar or better outcomes as public schools with less taxpayer funding.

More Reading

Post navigation

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *