A 400-pound student is taking legal action against Wayne State University for $1 million for not permitting him to instruct physical education online during his training as a student teacher. He alleges that this is discriminatory based on his weight and disability, as reported by The Detroit News.
David Lopez, a middle-aged student, suffers from diabetes, asthma, and hypertension. He claims to have completed all the requirements for the physical education/kinesiology program, except the student teaching component. Due to his physical limitations, Lopez stated that he “could not stand or walk for prolonged periods.” Although the school district he was assigned to accommodate his request to teach online, Wayne State reportedly did not.
Lopez managed to complete the first part of his student teaching assignment with the help of a gym teacher at his assigned school and “some unofficial accommodations.” Nevertheless, he alleged that Wayne State instructed him “not to report” for the second part. According to Lopez, the school was not allowing him to graduate with his certification due to his body size and weight. The Detroit News quoted Lopez as saying, “There’s no doubt that was the reason why. There was no other reason. I passed everything…It got to the point where I had no other choice left. I left with no degree, no certification, no nothing.”
One of his professors purportedly advised him to leave the university with a degree but without a teaching certificate. The professor allegedly expressed doubts about his fitness for the role of a gym teacher. Despite his physical limitations, Lopez asserts that his weight does not impede his ability to be an effective teacher.
Wayne State considers Lopez’s lawsuit “frivolous” and pointed out that there is no legal basis for weight discrimination against an educational institution under Michigan state law or federal law. The university also emphasized that weight is not a protected characteristic under Michigan’s public accommodation laws or school-specific civil-rights laws.
Disability discrimination by colleges is prohibited under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act. However, these laws do not mandate colleges to make fundamental alterations to accommodate a disabled person. Allowing virtual teaching, rather than in-person instruction, for a physical education teacher, which usually requires in-person teaching, could be deemed a “fundamental alteration” of the job, according to Southeastern Community College v. Davis (1979). Therefore, Lopez’s claim of disability discrimination might not succeed.

Leave a Comment