In the past, Democratic lawmakers in states such as Wisconsin and Texas left when the legislature was in session to prevent Republican-controlled legislatures from passing conservative laws. In Oregon, some conservative lawmakers also left during session to stop a left-wing Democratic legislature from passing left-wing laws.
Now, a liberal federal judge has ruled that Oregon lawmakers who are not present at the legislature to hinder it from having a quorum can be prohibited from running for reelection. The judge dismissed the First Amendment challenge of conservative lawmakers who were frequently absent. Legal experts anticipate the judge’s ruling will stand if appealed.
Here is an excerpt from Linthicum v. Wagner, a December 13 court ruling by Judge Ann Aiken of the U.S. District Court for Oregon:
The Oregon Constitution mandates that each chamber of the Oregon legislature must have a two-thirds quorum to conduct business. Or. Const. art IV, § 12. In recent years, the legislature has been intermittently paralyzed by walkouts in which members of the minority party absent themselves to deny the legislature a quorum.
In response to these walkouts, Oregon voters overwhelmingly approved Measure 113 in 2022 to amend the Oregon Constitution to penalize excessive absences by legislators. Following the passage of Measure 113, Article IV, section 15 of the Oregon Constitution was amended to read as follows:
Either house may punish its members for disorderly behavior, and may with the concurrence of two thirds, expel a member; but not a second time for the same cause. Failure to attend, without permission or excuse, ten or more legislative floor sessions called to transact business during a regular or special legislative session shall be deemed disorderly behavior and shall disqualify the member from holding office as a Senator or Representative for the term following the election after the member’s current term is completed.
Starting on May 3, 2023, a group of Oregon state senators from the minority party staged a walkout, depriving the chamber of a quorum…. The walkout lasted until late June 2023 and, by then, ten state senators, including the Senator Plaintiffs, had accumulated more than ten unexcused absences. The state senators were disqualified from seeking reelection based on Measure 113, and a challenge to that decision is currently pending before the Oregon Supreme Court….
For the purpose of this motion [for a preliminary injunction, the parties focus their dispute on … whether participation in the legislative walkout by the Senator Plaintiffs is constitutionally protected activity. The First Amendment “has no application when what is restricted is not protected speech.” … [T]hese walkouts were not simply protests—they were an exercise of the Senator Plaintiffs’ official power and were meant to deprive the legislature of the power to conduct business.
Whether the lawmaker is present in the chamber to debate and vote on a bill or leaves the chamber to prevent a quorum, both actions are similar in that they are an exercise of the lawmaker’s office power. The Supreme Court has held that performing the functions of a lawmaker are not a personal privilege but a public responsibility. In Nevada Commission on Ethics v. Carrigan (2011), the Supreme Court held that “a legislator’s vote is the commitment of his apportioned share of the legislature’s power to the passage or defeat of a particular proposal,” and “[t]he legislative power thus committed is not personal to the legislator but belongs to the people; the legislator has no personal right to it.” Put more simply, “the procedures for voting in legislative assemblies pertain to lawmakers not as individuals but as political representatives executing the legislative process.”
As a result, the Supreme Court “rejected the notion that the First Amendment confers a right to use governmental mechanics to convey a message” and held that “a lawmaker has no right to use official powers for expressive purposes.” “Moreover, the fact that a nonsymbolic act is the product of deeply held personal belief—even if the actor would like it to convey his deeply held personal belief—does not transform action into First Amendment speech.”
The facts in Carrigan involved a lawmaker being prevented by a recusal law from voting or speaking on a particular matter before the state legislature. However, the same rationale can be applied to provisions which are intended to compel attendance at the legislature. Indeed, the United State Congress is empowered by the Constitution itself to “compel the Attendance of absent Members, in such Manner, and under such Penalties as each House may provide.” U.S. Const. Art. I, § 5. It has been long recognized that these penalties may be as severe as arrest and imprisonment.
The Supreme Court has held that “[a] universal and long-established tradition of prohibiting certain conduct creates a strong presumption that the prohibition is constitutional.” If no less a body than the United States Congress may compel the attendance of its members by imprisonment without running afoul of the First Amendment, then the Court cannot see how a lesser penalty, such as temporary disqualification, or the threat of temporary disqualification, for the same conduct would constitute a violation of the free speech rights of the Senator Plaintiffs.
In conclusion, the Court determines that the use of legislative walkouts is not constitutionally protected activity under the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment, and therefore, based on this record, Plaintiffs have not demonstrated either a likelihood of success on the merits or serious questions regarding the merits of their claim for First Amendment retaliation….

Leave a Comment