Harvard University President Claudine Gay is accused of plagiarism. Her doctoral dissertation in 1997 “contains three clear examples of plagiarism according to Harvard’s own policy,” reports Campus Reform. Scholars and journalists “are criticizing the university for possibly hiring her based on identity politics rather than merit. The allegations of Gay’s plagiarism came to light shortly after she made headlines for stating before Congress that the acceptability of ‘calling for the massacre of Jews’ at Harvard ‘depends on context.'”
According to a report by two journalists, “Gay’s 1997 dissertation, ‘Taking Charge: Black Electoral Success and the Redefinition of American Policies,’ includes three instances of direct plagiarism. This includes a paragraph that is taken ‘almost word for word’ from a paper titled ‘Race, Sociopolitical Participation, and Black Empowerment’ by Lawrence Bobo and Franklin Gilliam.”
“Gay seems to have copied material from scholar Carol Swain at least twice.” Additionally, she included “an entire appendix in the dissertation directly taken from Gary King’s book, A Solution to the Ecological Inference Problem.”
Gay appears to have avoided scrutiny because of her emphasis on diversity, equality, and inclusion (DEI), which made her untouchable at Harvard. Another journalist states that Claudine Gay “was a DEI hire. Affirmative action hires are simply incompetent. DEI hires are deliberate advocates for the ideology that fosters anti-Semitism and animosity toward ‘non-preferred groups’ including whites and Asians.”
As observed by Campus Reform,
“In the time since Gay’s testimony, scholars have noted that she lacks the intellectual credentials typically expected of a university president. New Mexico Associate Psychology Professor Geoffrey Miller pointed out on X that Gay has only written 11 peer-reviewed journal papers. ‘That’s approximately the number typically needed to be hired as a first-year tenure-track assistant professor at a respectable state university,’ wrote Miller.”
Miller further acknowledged that today’s university “administrators function more like party political officers in communist Russian or Chinese universities.” He added, “I mean ‘party’ quite literally: the Democratic party.”
“Additionally, an increasing number of them are entirely committed identitarian Leftists: they often launched their careers with a short series of papers on left-leaning topics, using left-leaning ideological frameworks, published in left-leaning journals – prior to shifting to the administrative track that offers much more political power to propagandize, indoctrinate, and control,” stated Miller.
Under Gay’s leadership, Harvard has disregarded violations of rules and disruptive behavior by pro-Hamas demonstrators, behavior it would have penalized if committed by conservatives.
As law professor David Bernstein notes, “the main issue with how many campuses” such as Harvard “are managing pro-Hamas protests currently is not a failure to prohibit ‘hate speech,’ — which should not be barred on college campuses — but a failure to enforce existing, content-neutral rules against misconduct such as entering classrooms to disrupt class with loud protests that make it impossible to hear the professor.” History professor KC Johnson points out, “recent disruptive anti-Israel protests [at Harvard] – students with bullhorns interrupting classes, etc – were organized by unacknowledged student groups. They ‘technically are not allowed to stage on-campus demonstrations,’ because of their unrecognized status. So ‘Why hasn’t Harvard enforced its rules?'”
Colleges have permitted masked pro-Hamas rallies in states like Virginia, which prohibit public mask-wearing except for Halloween and health reasons, even though colleges would never tolerate mask-wearing right-wing protesters. This ideological bias based on the perspective of protesters contradicts Supreme Court decisions such as Police Department v. Mosley (1972), which stated that pro-union protesters could not be allowed to picket if other groups were not allowed to picket. The Virginia Court of Appeals has upheld Virginia’s mask ban, but left-wing prosecutors like Steve Descano won’t enforce it against pro-Hamas protesters. Despite Code of Virginia § 18.2-422 clearly stating, “It shall be unlawful for any person over 16 years of age to, with the intent to conceal his identity, wear any mask, hood or other device whereby a substantial portion of the face is hidden or covered so as to conceal the identity of the wearer, to be or appear in any public place…However, the provisions of this section shall not apply to persons (i) wearing traditional holiday costumes….”
Colleges are applying campus rules against inappropriate remarks selectively. The University of Southern California and Washington University in St. Louis investigated professors for anti-Hamas remarks deemed dehumanizing toward Palestinians. But at Cornell University, there was no investigation of a professor who described the Hamas terror attacks “exhilarating” and “exciting.”
A diversity and inclusion director at Cornell University supported the Hamas terror attack, writing that Hamas was “fighting for life, dignity, and freedom…against settler colonization,Imperialism, capitalism, and white supremacy, which the United States exemplifies.”
“Colleges that routinely oppose microaggressions, Supreme Court decisions, Republican laws, and occurrences like students wearing sombreros to Halloween parties could not condemn the Hamas terror attacks that killed at least 1400 people, or campus protests that openly praised the terror attacks. One university stated it must stay neutral on “geopolitical issues and news events.” Such universities have often taken stances on political matters, such as climate change policy, and spoken out about news events, such as the death of George Floyd.”
“Northwestern University, which publicly criticized the Supreme Court for ruling against race-based college admissions, declined to “make an institutional statement” about the terror attacks by Hamas that killed relatives of some of its students.”
“Hamas seized many civilians, including young children, from neighboring Israel as hostages. Some of these hostages are American citizens. This hostage-taking came after the Biden administration accepted a $6 billion ransom to Iran for the release of five American hostages. Hamas acknowledges Iran provided it with weapons used in the attack on Israel. The Biden administration released millions of dollars to the Hamas-controlled government of the Gaza strip.”

Leave a Comment