College Edits Anti-Abortion Student’s Instagram Comment

The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression is urging a Texas community college to stop censoring a student’s anti-abortion views criticizing an event with Planned Parenthood, the largest abortion provider in the country.

A civil-liberties group from Philadelphia has given McLennan Community College until December 1 to address claims that the college violated the First Amendment by deleting pro-life student Madison Evans’s comment.

After an arm of the community college posted about a Planned Parenthood event, Evans responded on October 17, stating, “the killing of innocent babies is not a positive occurrence. As a student, I am disappointed & disgusted that the loss of innocent lives is being encouraged.” The administrator managing the account then removed her comment.

An administrator affirmed the college’s stance regarding comment deletion at a meeting on October 18, stating, “MCC’s social media accounts are not suitable platforms for voicing concerns about the values of another community organization,” Associate Director of Marketing and Communications Jennifer Norman informed Evans.

FIRE disagreed, stating:

That viewpoint contradicts the First Amendment, which public colleges must comply with. When government officials, including public college administrators, create venues for open discussion, whether in person or online, the First Amendment prohibits the regulation of speech within the venue. Viewpoint discrimination is prohibited, as established in longstanding precedent.

FIRE pointed out that a federal court had previously ruled that a county board’s Facebook page qualifies as a public forum where restrictions based on viewpoints are not allowed. The ruling also indicated that restrictions based on content are not allowed unless specifically tailored to serve a compelling interest.

FIRE argued that Evans’s comment “was relevant engagement with the Instagram post that Planned Parenthood was coming to campus to connect with students, and CREW’s decision to delete the comment silenced that part of the discourse surrounding this contentious political and cultural debate.”

“CREW’s Instagram administrators’ selective removal of Evans’ critical yet relevant comment is textbook viewpoint discrimination,” said FIRE’s letter.

College administrators “may not suppress disfavored views when moderating social media commentary on accounts open to public posts.”

“Nothing in the law requires public colleges to manage an Instagram account, but the law does impose obligations when they choose to do so.”

More Reading

Post navigation

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *